Join CNN’s Surprise Principle science publication. Discover the universe with information on fascinating discoveries, scientific developments and extra.
CNN
—
A lone diver first laid eyes on the traditional Kyrenia shipwreck off the north coast of Cyprus practically 60 years in the past. However when archaeologists tried to find out the precise timeline of the vessel coming to a relaxation on the ocean flooring, they had been left to invest primarily based on the ship’s cargo.
Now, a new examine revealed Wednesday within the journal PLOS One could have a greater time estimate of the Kyrenia’s demise — and the revelation got here collectively due to newly cleaned wooden samples from the ship, in addition to clues supplied by a twig, an animal bone and a cache of historical almonds.
Native diver Andreas Cariolou first found the Kyrenia ship, one of many first main Greek Hellenistic-period ships to be discovered largely intact, in 1965, and a workforce led by the late marine archaeologist Michael Katzev excavated the wreck and its cargo within the late ’60s.
The researchers initially believed the vessel sank round 300 BC. One textual content, the primary quantity of the location’s remaining studies revealed in 2022, estimated a spread of 294 BC to 290 BC, primarily based on pottery and a few cash discovered on board. However there was no scientific courting obtainable to again up the estimates, based on the most recent examine.
By utilizing radiocarbon courting — a technique used to find out the age of natural supplies, reminiscent of wooden from bushes — and dendrochronology, the science of courting tree rings, the researchers of the brand new examine decided the Kyrenia’s sinking occurred between 296 BC and 271 BC. They usually discovered a robust likelihood that it occurred between 286 BC and 272 BC, the examine authors wrote.
“We acquired dates which might be very shut to those who archaeologists have been just lately suggesting however simply ever so barely more moderen,” mentioned lead creator Sturt Manning, distinguished professor of arts and sciences in classical archaeology at Cornell College in New York.
Whereas an up to date timeline supported by scientific information is necessary for the well-known ship, the pivotal revelation is in new methods and a revised radiocarbon calibration that may assist scientists extra precisely date constructions and shipwrecks from this era, Manning mentioned.
Two major obstacles stood in the way in which of reaching a high-precision age estimate for the Kyrenia shipwreck, based on Manning. The primary was that polyethylene glycol or PEG, a petroleum-derived compound used to preserve the ship’s wooden, was interfering with radiocarbon courting.
Usually, shipwrecks stay effectively preserved as a result of lack of oxygen on the backside of the ocean. However as soon as the supplies are introduced as much as the floor, they rapidly deteriorate, Manning defined. Injecting polyethylene glycol into the wooden retains the timber from crumbling and turning into powder, but it surely then turns into troublesome to take away with time.
“You solely have to have actually a fraction of a p.c of these items (polyethylene glycol) on there, and the date will probably be improper, typically by a whole bunch, if not 1000’s of years,” mentioned Manning, who had tried to this point the Kyrenia ship 10 years in the past however failed due to PEG.
Nonetheless, a world workforce of researchers developed a cleansing protocol, described in an October 2021 examine, that efficiently eliminated the petroleum-based compound from wooden that was pretty just lately conserved, Manning mentioned. To substantiate that the protocol would work with one thing as previous because the Kyrenia shipwreck, Manning and his colleagues utilized the method to a bit of PEG-preserved wooden they knew to be from practically 2,000 years in the past and located correct radiocarbon ages.
Now with an answer to scrub the wooden, the researchers thought they’d be capable to date the ship’s wooden. However they encountered a second roadblock as an alternative and stored receiving ages that didn’t match “any attainable archaeological answer round,” Manning mentioned.
After investigating, he and his workforce decided that the Northern Hemisphere worldwide radiocarbon calibration curve, the conversion of measurements to dates primarily based on recognized tree rings, was outdated for the interval between about 400 BC and 250 BC.
The researchers had been capable of formulate their date estimate by recalibrating the curve utilizing sequoia and oak samples of recognized age from this era. The revised curve was important to homing in on an correct timeframe for the Kyrenia shipwreck and will additional assist researchers internationally dealing with comparable issues when courting historical constructions, Manning mentioned.
The radiocarbon ages from the wooden gave the researchers an concept of when the ship was constructed, but it surely was a cargo of almonds that gave the examine authors a date estimate for when the shipwreck occurred, Manning mentioned. “In the event you’ve acquired materials like almonds — or you may think about olives or something like this which was getting used as a meals crop — and it was on the ship when it sank, it’s acquired to have been there from most likely a couple of 12 months … or possibly it was two years older than when a ship went down.”
By utilizing the natural supplies from the cargo, such because the almonds, an unidentified wooden twig that was not a part of the ship’s construct, and an ankle bone of livestock, researchers had been capable of slender the dates and estimate a spread of years for when the Kyrenia ship’s final voyage passed off.
“A part of the worth of this story is about course of. … the (radiocarbon) courting and dendrochronology fields have grown, developed, refined their outcomes over many many years,” mentioned Mark Lawall, a professor within the division of classics on the College of Manitoba in Winnipeg, in an e mail. “Science — whether or not ‘onerous’ or ‘gentle’ — develops over time via lots of work ‘within the trenches’. It takes time and it wants time.” He was not concerned within the new examine.
With the slight modification within the estimated sinking date, it’s spectacular that the unique dates primarily based on archaeological proof of ceramics and cash had been solely off by just a few years, mentioned Lawall, who has studied amphorae, historical Greek containers used for transport wine, olive oil and different items, from the Kyrenia shipwreck.
“The opposite a part of the Kyrenia story is its window into previous lives which might be in any other case troublesome to ‘see’ via the well-known historical writers (and even much less recognized),” Lawall mentioned. “The Kyrenia crew could have been a band of extra marginal merchants, taking on what they may, the place and after they may, and hoping for a small revenue on the finish of the day.”
He added, “They dealt throughout cultures and in doing so had been a part of an immensely advanced community that tied all elements of the Mediterranean collectively. On this manner we begin to perceive the origins of the fashionable, multi-cultural, inter-linked Mediterranean world.”